With this fourth consecutive post on Swades, this blog is likely to become the unofficial Swades fan club. He he!
But after I watched the movie again, my respect for this movie has gone up by a few notches. People, this movie is a CLASSIC. And the background score simply rocks. I find the theme score pretty haunting, too bad it’s not on the CD… it’s the music that appears during the opening credits and later in the climax with a mission impossible feel.
Here are some of the things I noticed watching it the second time.
SPOILER ALERT: Well, don’t read ahead if you are very touchy about details and specifics and would want to find them out for yourself. But come on, this isn’t exactly a thriller. And there’s no climax. It’s not the kind of movie you would watch for the story as such but the kind you will worship for the narrative (the way a story is told).
So here we go, the Swades trivia:
The bookshop where Mohan meets Gita for the first time, and asks her for the way to Charanpur, is called Pathfinder.
When Mohan is at the book counter, there is a book called Bapu Kutir, by Rajni Bakshi. That’s the book credited at the beginning of the movie. Apparently, it was Rajni Bakshi who told Ashutosh about the real life hydro-electricity project and AID.
The village Charanpur which represents every element of India – caste diversities, the soil, the water resources, the problems of illiteracy, lack of infrastructure and a selfless Mother India in Kauveri-amma who in her very introduction scene is shown grooming yet another new born infant. The village Panchayat too has the same variety of characters as the Indian government would. First, of all, the Panchayat system is a coalition of five people, out of which one guy has a Laloo hairstyle and declares ‘hamra des duniya ka sabse mahaan des hai.’ There’s also a Fatima Beevi, a woman and from the minority community in the five running the village. Pretty much representative of the Indian system.
In the scene where the entire village watches ‘Yaadon Ki Baarat’ sitting on either side of the screen, Ashutosh uses plenty of cues. The movie sequence to suggest that the entire village irrespective of caste and creed (which represents every element of India in the film) gets together only during a movie, so true of India where cinema is religion.
Hence, Mohan uses the same canvas used for cinema during the power-cut to deliver his message of unity through the song ‘Yeh Taara Woh Tara.’ You can easily draw a parallel with Ashutosh using the medium of cinema and stars like Shah Rukh Khan to get his message across to the Indian population. The silhouette of Shah Rukh Khan (raising his arm, his typical regular standard steps and body language) on the canvas further substantiates the point. It is only in this song that Shah Rukh Khan is Shah Rukh Khan and not Mohan Bhargav. Swades needed a star to endorse the message. SRK was the star.
The movie is aptly titled ‘Yaadon Ki Baarat’ to take NRIs watching the movie down memory lane. The movie is about siblings SEPARATED due to circumstances. Aamir Khan plays the youngest son in that clip of ‘Yaadon Ki Baarat.’
To suggest separation and reunion, Ashutosh borrows heavily from two of India’s greatest tales – Ramayan and Mahabharath. Mohan is another name for Krishna, who was brought up by Yashodha. In the movie, Mohan is actually raised not by his own mother but by his nanny Kauveri Amma who he refers to as Yashodha in the scene when he meets her in the village after a decade.
In another occasion, in a direct reference during the Ramleela song (which has now been edited out of the movie by exhibitors), the director draws parallels between Gayatri Joshi as Gita playing Sita who is in Ravan’s captivity (Sita, according to the Ramayan, incidentally is the daughter of mother earth). Gita in the movie is the daughter of the soil, who stands for the ‘sanskar’ and ‘parampara.’ She was kidnapped when Ram was away during the exile of around 12 years, exactly the around the same number of years that Mohan was away from India.
The fictitious village is called Charanpur because it housed the temple that is supposed to have foot imprints of Ram and Sita.
On a lighter note, Gita is also the book of advice, which the heroine gives out liberally throughout to Mohan. 😉
Mohan when he meets Kauveri-amma for the first time, does not sip water that she gives him. He just puts it away (a close-up registers that the tumbler is still full) subtly. He’s also shown to be carrying a month’s supply of mineral water bottles.
But later when he meets the boy at the railway station selling water for 25 paise, a visibly shaken Mohan takes a sip from that tumbler. He doesn’t care if it’s contaminated. This is his country. The moment of epiphany.
On day one, Mohan wakes up from his caravan and has his bath inside the caravan too. In the course of the movie, the director shows him sleeping on the cot only to wake up and say ‘I haven’t had such deep sleep in a long time.’ And seems to be enjoying his bath by the well.
In one of the songs, Gita makes Mohan set foot into the temple tank. He does that and feels really good about it. This is when he’s just set foot into the country, nothing more. Later in the end when he’s completely surrendered to the country, he has a wash from the same temple tank as he uses that water to wash his body of the soil that is now part of him (the last frame of the movie).
Sudish
It looks as if you are all over Swades. Anyways, talking about moments of epiphany, Dilip D’Souza (a journo whose column is claimed to have inspired Swades) writes about some moments of epiphany in his blog… Do check it out
http://dcubed.blogspot.com/2004/12/moments-of-epiphany.html
with all ur swades posts, u r making me feel awful for not being able to see the movie. Its not playing at any of the theatres near my house over here:( Guess thats good in one way too, I dont want to become homesick in the midst of the holliday season.
jesus christ!! swades is too trivial a movie to write trivia on!! yeah yeah…social message and all that…but gawd..what a boring waste! 4 frigging posts on that goddamn crappy movie! you are crazier than me!!
Sankalp…thank your stars..if you watch it, you’ll feel even more awful..
I still haven’t watched the movie. And the 4th consecutive post.. I don’t know what it did to others, but it certainly rubbed the fact in. Deep! 😦
But you know what.. I’m gonna redirect a whole lotta traffic towards ur blog, Suderman.. My friends have all been sayin it’s slow, preachy and boring. I’m pretty certain ur blog will do the trick. 🙂
btw, now u’ve really psyched me up. One more post about Swades before I get to watch the movie… and I jus might cry! 🙂
This movie talks to people in different level. I like the honest approach. Where the charters full fill there commitments.. Mohan does not throw away the job at NASA but stays till the project gets over to make move… In the end mohan talks to the audience saying “if you can’t understand me you have to come home to realize what i mean” and the dialog between Fatima Beevi giving Kaveri amma “Ice melts in it’s own water”.
On the other hand Mohan is conveniently single with no family commitment either in US or in India…
I feel don’t have to go back home to do good things for India. One fine example for this point is AIMS India.. There are several other such NRI who can help our country while being a SWADESI…
True Sudish..it has a hangover on me more than any other films have done. Forget even VZ. I was sure Swades would have a bigger hangover. Its a class act. Read my review at my blog http://avlokana.blogspot.com
Thanks Sud. Neat blog he has. Its not just claims, Rajni Bakshi did tell Ashutosh about Dilip’s column… and the scene described in his column is there in the movie. the bulb coming on to light up the face of the tribal woman. one of the awesome moments in the movie!
sankalp,
Its a must watch movie, dont believe dick-heads and assholes who have scant respect for emotions attached towards the country of their origin…
oh yeah, talkin about assholes, make me an exception! 😉
sudhon!!
jesus christ ah??
watha… jesus ur thatha wah? N u wash ur underwear in washington huh… lemme guess you roll your ‘R’s and slant your ‘A’s and bend hard to lick American ass!
Kaaaaaaaaaaaaaaakh Thu! (Thats the sound of spit on ur face my friend)
Thank god u aren’t standing facing me or my fist would have loved to explore ur face!
Three words for u… Die. bitch. die.
Having said that, I’m glad you had the balls to put ur name and din’t sign off anonymous!
Seriously dude, you need to come here and see what your country is really all about before you rest your ass miles away and pass sad ass judgement that makes your ass and face look the same and you know whats worse… looks like they produce the same thing too!
Harish,
dude… the tickets are available at ega! plenty of em… too bad our own people believe that they know it all and they don’t need messages! Ha hubris… the situation where the patient believes that he actually taught his dad how to make babies!
Karthek,
I dont think they need to come back either.
I think some of them, people like sudhon are better off there. Since we have a population problem, it’s best to get rid of people who think they know it all!
But our country will progress without or without NRIs coming back… they aren’t our biggest strength in any case… our biggest strength is our people in the villages and manpower. with the spread of education to the remotest of districts, we are on the road to to development.
the lines in the movie do make a lot of sense but I still am not totally for all our NRIs coming back. In fact, they could just generate more money there and plough it back in India. We really need their money.
Vin,
I just left a comment in ur blog. chk it out. Cheers man!
sudhish thambi!
language!??!!! buddy, watch it!
btw, dint read this post. it might not be a thriller, but i like to watch my movies.
sudhon man. give us a break. watch a movie b4 u trash it.
cheers,
ramya
ha ha yakkow ramya!
no no… sudhon himself doesnt believe in moral policing! he’s used to this kinda language! besides when did i say my blog is for children??
Hi Sudhish,4 posts consecutively on a single movie…. then must watch it asap,actually after reading that Rediff review on Swades ,i was so keen on watching this one as Rediff always has the tradition of negatively reviewing a good film,but the problem is i can’t understand hindi that well,….what’s the better idea..take a buddy who knows hindi(won’t that be irritating?),or watch the tamil version….or risking all the way to watch it in Hindi..won’t it be a better idea,if these kinda movies are sub-titled rather than dubbed…Being a media person..write on this..coz ,i feel the crowd out here to watch ‘masala’ movies won’t watxch ‘Swades’ anyway even if dubbed.Ppl like me wanting to see good movies only watch it..but it will be sick to watch a dubbed movie..so Sub titling is the best option.What’s ur comment
-Muthuvel
Muthuvel
Any movie or problem that touches the grassroots doesn’t require a language… You will understand the feelings almost sub consciously… The needs of the people at the grassroots are elementary and you will understand it if they say it in Konkani or in Bojpuri…I think Swades is one such movie…
Coming to my own personal experience, I went to a talk in Austin by a person named Rajendra Singh.. He belongs to a group called Tarun Bharat Sangh and he is based in Rajasthan. He has done some unbelievable work in rainwater harvesting and water management in certain districts of Rajasthan. He spoke in Hindi and my Hindi is as good as his Tamil. But somehow, those 90 minutes , I could understand every single word he said..
Your reviews/trivias on the movie has definitely made an impact (on me anyway). I intend to watch it as soon as possible with my son. The only issue now remains is the language! The young one’s second language is Hindi and I get totally lost with Hindi. Should I see the Hindi version and fall asleep as I won’t understand anything or do I take him to see the Tamil version and listen to him whining as he will be struggling to understand. I am with Muthuvel on this, subtitles would have made my life a whole lot easier!
Uma
Ha! cant take a lil criticism can you? that too of the movie and not you! look whos talking about childishness…go on..go run crying… “mummmmmyyyy…that bad boy is telling bad things about my fav moviee…wah wah waaah boooo hooooo”. 3 words for you too my dear friend…cry. baby. cry.
Atleast I wash my undies man…but from the stink here..I doubt if you even do that! If I’ve got an ass for my face, what were you thinking when you loved to explore my ass with your dirty fist? My shit comes out…I dont have it stored inside my skull like you..with brains like that, its no wonder that you dont understand that I criticized the movie and not the concept or the message! there is more to a movie in case you didnt know…casting, direction, acting, screenplay, dialogues, music, humor, entertainment to name a few..
Edho naan america la ye porandhu valarndhavan madhiri nee pesura? Its been only a coupla months since I came here..I am a native of an agricultural village..I lived my life in Madras…I know what my country is like…I have experienced it..I am not so bleeding a retard that I need a goddamn stupid movie to make me realise the problems my country faces!
I am already a part of the chapter of AID in my univ and have worked my ass, sorry my face, off for it. I have been a volunteer for innumerable charity/welfare activities back in madras. I believe in doing…in actions…not lazing in a couch, appreciating a crappy movie, act as if it has affected you, write posts and comments on the issue, and do nothing more….forget all about it and continue your normal life the next morning..seriously…let’s see how many of the people who were so “touched” by that excuse of a movie actually do something about it..
Fine journo you make dood..really..let’s see you as an editor replying to your letters like this. And as you say…I am only used to this kinda language..I dont use it. I am not even gonna care to spit on your face man…I dont want my spit to get dirty.
Ramya..I made the mistake of watching the movie and almost died of boredom. I’ll maintain that as a movie, it is a BORE and a message doesn’t make it the most interesting one.
sudhon,
1. if i were editor, i wd just chuck ur crappy letter into the bin. Your comment TOTALLY REJECTED! 🙂 it doesnt take much to delete it dude.
I’m just keeping it here to showcase ur I-know-it-all hubris…
2. dude, u must be a total loser to come back and check my blogs this often after all the nice things u have to say about me. lets hear another desperate attempt to sound smart, I’m waiting.
3. poi rendum maasam aagala… ena airport accent ah??
and since u dint spit on me and lost ur chance, I spit on u yet again! I have no such qualms about dirtying my spit… he he!
4. what else? Oh the stink of the underwear all the way there… dude, it just means u’re not washing urs well enuff then. and well u answered the point urself urself… that’s exactly the reason why i resisted the urge of my fist to explore your face… it looked so much like ur ass!
5. and i dint call u childish at all, where did u pick that up from? I love such fights, I’m all for it. Especially when I get to kick so much butt! 😀
6. Talkin of criticism, waddya know about filmmaking that Ashutosh Gowariker does not? About ur AID claims, may God bless you if u really have done something in the two months u’ve been there. but i know that people who do indulge in development work, dont spend too much time making themselves look like Mother Teresas. Besides, being an AID volunteer, you shd know that development communication is about reaching the grassroots and the biggest vehicle for grassroots communication in India is mainstream commercial cinema! Swades deserves all the praise cuz no one has ever had the balls to even attempt somethin like this ever before. At least get your basics right before you end up making a complete ass of yourself yet again… As for the slanging match, I sooo love it…
Violence is a good discharge of bad energy. Bad language comes close.
Uma
The movie is not really for children.
its for a slightly grown up audience, the movie’s targetted at NRIs and yes, it’s been dubbed in regional languages to appeal to the secondary audience and reach the grassroots.
Im sure you can watch it in Hindi and understand it as it is.
“The movie is not really for children” – Didn’t think so, but as I won’t be allowed to do anything without the young man being involved during the holidays, I will have to watch it with him. It might even be an ideal film for an opinionated 11 year old with strong views on society. Who knows? Four whole days to go before I get to Indiaaaah.
Uma
You love slanging matches eh? The Australian cricket team can make good use of you! :p Everyone loves to kick butt dood…that doesn’t mean you summa start a fight just cos you are all for it. If you as an editor are gonna toss my letter into the bin, it shows the sad state of journalism these days. So biased. Selective as hell. You are being as selective as the stupid American media is in sucking the president’s seval.
Just cos you think a movie is good, and I think it was stupid and boring, doesn’t mean my letter is crappy. I can’t express an opinion on a movie that’s different from what the esteemed reviewer thinks? Did I pass personal insults at you? No. All I said that the movie was, to quote exactly, “a boring waste…and goddamn crappy”. Why does that freak you out so much that you have to sling it out at a personal level in such a disgusting manner? You dont have to prove that you are capable of publishing a Mariamma Kupster’s Dictionary of Cheri Tamil Slang.
I know ZILCH about filmmaking. There is no absolutely need to know to enjoy a movie. It doesnt matter to me what went into the movie…it only matters how the movie comes out..and how entertaining it was. Guts doesn’t make a movie good. Even Simbu had the balls to attempt something like Manmadhan. Praise that? Bowling for Columbine is an example of a first and a bloody good. Swades is a first maybe, but not good. BfC and 9/11 do everything you said..commercial, mainstream, grassroot. They give you the message on the rocks. Manga adi. Not diluted with the usual senti love shit and stale humor. At the same time, much more entertaining and funny. Our country needs something like that.
Those nice things about you are in my comment box. All of those nice things were not MY comments. My comments were on your articles in the Hindu..not personal insults…I never swear at people in blogs. Why I visited your blog a few times? Cos you are a co-blogger who visited my blog. Cos I think your humor works well on blogs. Its terribly outta place in the Hindu but not here. “another desperate attempt to sound smart”. you hit the nail on the head there…thats exactly how your articles in the newspaper sound. And as you saw, I wasnt the only one who thought so. And yeah, cos I thought you were a good sport. Guess I was wrong.
Still wanna slang it out? Bring it on.
thambi sudhon…
u sounded a lil smarter and wittier on the offensive in ur earlier comment.
on the defensive, u’re sounding more like a loser running outta arguments!
i dont have to tell u this. u r educated boy. america developed country. english speaking, educated country. bowling for columbine, fahrenheit 911 however biased (and dramatic if i may add) they may be, how much ever propaganda they have mite work, cuz there ppl watch it as a documentary-a work of fact and are educated enuff to still go ahead and vote for bush, however screwed up he may be.
india… local people, they watch movie for entertainment not education. there lies the basic flaw in ur argument. they need to be told a tale in a language they understand, in a formula they understand with a star they can relate to!
and about why i abused u… cuz i dont like u bcuz of the way u think… simple… just like how u dont like me or the way i write! i can only give u the respect which u give me. underwear now?
I’m glad that u’ve agreed u know zilch about filmmaking. i’ll be gladder if u make an attempt to understand the kind of entertainment ur countrymen turn to and begin to respect them for their tastes, beliefs and attitudes… and acknowledge sincere effort with whatever minimum grace you can spare for lesser mortals!
u need not say nice things about the film but you can surely abstain from rubbishing genuine efforts which are rare to find in a market driven by commerce.
And thanks for ur assurance of how my humour works in a blog and not in the paper… i was contemplating stabbing myself to death you know! watha dai… i am not the gentleman types to give diplomatic answers or say ‘pass’ to a street fight… more like captain, vettiya madichu kattina.. vettu onnu thaan… thundu rendu thaan! 😀
And dont gimme shit about personal and professional criticism, how comment sections are different from blog sections… i dont really give a damn… a coupla friends told me about references to my story and my name specifically in ur blogs which is the reason why i checked your blog. and I reacted to it long ago (my blog post that reads Fighting Hubris). chapter closed then and there. so you dont need to get defensive now.
You said something rubbishing my opinion, I said a few things in my style rubbishing yours. Simple. Thats how any argument works. u hit, u get hit.
I (probably like u mite too) will take criticism from people i respect, people who i think make sense not from some dude who appears so stuck up in his blogs, his comments and pray, my comments section too… underwear now?
After erading all ur posts on Swades, I am not sure which I enjoyed more.. the movie or ur writings.. and that you must be aware is as high a compliment as it gets 🙂
Great work Suderman !! On my part, abs LOVED the movie…Here’s my take on the movie..
http://jupieee.blogspot.com/2004/12/we-people.html
http://jupieee.blogspot.com/2004/12/5-reasons-to-watch-story-of-mohan.html
ps: Damn.. I’ve been leaving behind a trail of URLs that one might suspect that I am trying to draw u in there.. dat was def NOT the intention.. Jes that we seem to think on similar lines for a lot of the movie stuff 🙂
That’s why India is in such a mess, you all hate each other so much. The old crab box not needing a lid.
after nearly one year, im putting up a Swades article on my blog.. Duh !!
Wondering why you hadnt mentioned the music part in this review.. Or may be it is a separate article.. let me check, hmm.
http://www.cs.odu.edu/~jsharma/swades/
Cool Video here
I found this blog while I was googling to find if there was a village named Charanpur in reality, after watching Swdesh. Thanks to AGPPL for such a nice movie. I was reading about some comment about this not being a kid’s movie, but my 3yr old daughter can’t get enough of ‘Eh Thara Woh Thara..’ song and SRK is ‘Eh Thara uncle’ in our house…. Yeah right!.
Did you notice that Mohan Bhargav hardly spoke american ? The only time he speaks in american english is when he says ‘Gawt it’ to Mela Ram, when they meet the first time. For most people who spend this many years in schools and work places in USA would have got a lot of words and style of speaking like americans. I Wonder if Ashutosh didn’t want it that way and why ?. I think it would have been natural if Mohan spoke that way too. And why does Shah Rukh Khan have to smoke in his every movie ?
On the whole it was a wonderful movie. The chemistry between Gita and Mohan was so appropriate, inspite of the fact that they were not all over each other physically. What a debut for Gayatri Joshi!, hope she gets many more like this and not disappear like Gracy Singh after Lagaan.
Hey there, all 4 of you, your Blog’s really cool. The video rocks. I’ve bookmarked you. Will send u my info later. Going out to buy a t-shirt now. I’ll buy a black one and print ” That Four Letter Word ” on it.
Surprised ! Well… when inspiration hits, it hits real hard. Hence the T-Shirt. Congratulations though, you just got a new fan. 🙂